Roz Crowley

Food, wine, travel, music

Soup survey 2013

This article first appeared in the Irish Examiner on 11 January 2013 and I have just realised it has been in the draft box of this blog since then. The soups are still available, at least the brands, so for what it’s worth here is my opinion of them.


Just Food organic tomato and roast vegetable 400g €2

All tasters liked this soup best immediately, agreeing on the lively tomato flavours being well balanced with parmiggiano reggiano, olive oil, fresh basil and walnuts.  The vibrant red to orange colour from 35% tomatoes and 8% red peppers does not disappoint in the taste, and the natural texture of smooth courgette and aubergine is a good promotion for the organic ingredients. This makes a good base for main courses to add fish or meat for a quick supper. Good value.

Score 9.5

Glorious Meal soup – Sunny Thai chicken  600g €2.79

A deliciously lively lemongrass taste dominates this fresh soup which also has chickpeas, courgette, aubergine, celery , organic tomatoes and red peppers,  sweet potatoes, carrots, plenty of onions and leeks. 5% chicken is a decent amount in this mixture. There is quite a lot of coconut too to add to the Thai flavours, along with lime leaves and ginger. Tasters liked this as a substantial, flavoursome soup, which could do for a supper. In a perfect world it would be made in Ireland, but is from the UK, but still got top marks from tasters. Available in Dunnes Stores.

Score 9.25

Cully & Sully Chicken & Vegetable soup  400g €2

Quite a substantial soup with 4% chicken which has more flavour and better texture than other samples with more meat. Nicely creamy and buttery with natural tastes. Liked by all tasters. Fair price for this quality.

Score 9

Supervalu chicken & vegetable soup 400g €1.99

Creaminess is the predominant experience here with a feel of real cream and butter. The 5% shredded chicken tastes of chicken. There is also leek, carrot, celery and potato. Noted on the label are sulphites which can cause a reaction in consumers who are sensitive to them. There is also added modified potato starch, dextrose and an anti caking agent E551 which tasters prefer not to have in their food.

Score 7.5

 Baxters  Cream of Chicken400g €1.39

We looked at this canned soup to see how it stood up against fresh soups and if the flavours benefitted from the convenience of long life cans. Smooth and creamy, there are tasty pieces of chicken here and nice hints of white pepper.  At 1.2g per 200g portion, salt content is high. A satisfying old fashioned cream soup, while not as vibrant as some fresh soups, handy to have in the storecupboard.

Score 7

Nash 19 Seasonal soup 600g €3.95

A nicely natural, pulpy texture here was offset by a feeling that with such a rich chicken stock, the vegetables were a bit overpowered. A little cabbage flavour came through and tasters liked roast fennel, tomato and bean textures. The second favourite of tasters of the vegetable soups.

Score 8

 Marks & Spencer Super Green soup  600g  €3.70

Lots of cabbage flavour here with a light texture, not artificially thickened.  It’s green as it says on the label with 8% spinach and 5% spring cabbage. A light mint flavour seemed a bit out of season for winter, bur tasters liked it for a change.

Score 7


Avonmore Farmer’s Choice Mixed vegetable fresh soup  400g €1.99 1.2g salt per 200g portion

Chewy peas were the first thing complained about in this soups and tasters didn’t like the texture of the thickening of the soup either. No sense of fresh vegetables. Poor value for the price

Score: 4




Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on April 2, 2014 by in Food, Other, Surveys and tagged , , , , , , , .





%d bloggers like this: